Welcome to Collective Conversation Sign in | Join | Help

Boyd Neil

 
Boyd Neil on corporate social responsibility, transparency, dialogue, and digital "connectedness", which together are driving new corporate communications strategies

Justifying Journalism

I spoke at a media relations conference yesterday paradoxically on the topic of influencing public attitidues with direct communication strategies. Of course, I touched on my usual themes -- dialogue replacing monologue (shouting your message), dialgoue as "the art of thinking together" (William Isaacs), and the impact of social media on corporate communication strategies. The response was polite, with a bit more enthusiasm from a couple of people who work for NGOs.

But during those parts of the presentation where I rant about the declining importance of mainstream media when it comes to issue management, using examples like Intel's announcement about layoffs that was scooped by bloggers, I realized just how tough it is to be a newspaper or television reporter these days. Not only are newspaper jobs disappearing, and news room resources dwindling, but bloggers are also getting to stories hours, even days, before a reporter is on the case.

The question is How are reporters coping? What strategies are individual reporters using to justify their craft? Other than those fighting a rearguard action with complaints about 'no standards in the blogsphere', no fact checkers in social media, no training for citizen journalists, are some wondering just how valuable is their profession? If a thousand others can find news faster, can write with as much panache and meaning, and reach an influential audience, then what is the new role for mainstream scribes?

Just a thought.

Published 07 September 2006 18:53 by Boyd Neil
Filed under:

Comment Notification

If you would like to receive an email when updates are made to this post, please register here

Subscribe to this post's comments using RSS

Comments

  • Elliott Silverstein said:

    I've thought about your posting Boyd, and the thought that comes to mind over and again is the notion of the "market vs. commons" when it comes to the Internet.  A decade ago, people would talk about which would prevail as the definitive function of the 'net.  Much like the market and commons, I think that traditional and citizen journalists are ultimately going to need to co-exist in an ever changing and fragmenting environment.
    September 8, 2006 05:02

Leave a Comment

(required) 
(optional)
(required) 
Submit

About Boyd Neil

Boyd Neil is senior vice president and national practice director, corporate communications, Hill & Knowlton Canada.