Welcome to Collective Conversation Sign in | Join | Help

Change & Internal Communications

 
by David Ferrabee, MD Change & Internal Communications, London

Subscribe

News

YOU CAN NOW purchase my new book, People Power, at www.tinyurl.com/236l4z

It is a collection of the last two years of blogs, grouped into subject chapters and with new introductions, index and contents pages.

I need readers to write reviews on site too!

Thanks

Search

 Go

Post Calendar

<July 2008>
MoTuWeThFrSaSu
30123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031123
45678910

Ronaldo and employment slavery

 

LONDON -- It's a bit of a misnomer, isn't it?  Saying Ronaldo is a slave.  Even without a talk-radio station playing on my desk I can hear the punters saying "How can he be a slave when he's earning £120,000 a week?"

And you can't really argue with that.

The Portuguese footballer is only 23 years old.  He was bought and brought in to replace David Beckham as a teenager.  When Beckham (ironically) left the top global brand Manchester United to go and play at the possibly even bigger global branded team of Real Madrid.

But don't expect an ex-pat Canadian to have anything useful to say about football.  (With the possible exception of Calgary-bred Owen Hargreaves.)

I am however interested in the idea that a successful and well compensated individual can feel that he or she is held against their will by an employer.  Because, in some ways, I think it can be true.

Hear me out!

Changing jobs can often feel like a very difficult thing.  You have to change so many habits.  How do you get to work?  Do you have to move?  You need to set up new bank transfers.  Are there differences in the health cover? Who will your new boss be?  Will she be okay?  Will you still be able to meet Jenny for a Hagen-Daz every Thursday?

Okay, so there's more money, but is it that much, after taxes?  And what if you discover that you can't actually do what they think you can do?  (At least here we all know what each other can really do.)

So, there is a natural, human resistance to change that can hold you back.  And many, many companies... in fact most of the thousands that I have worked with... do very little to dissuade people from having that fear.  It's in the company's benefit for you to stay put:

  • You have fewer pay rises
  • They know you can do the job (sort of)
  • It costs about 150% of your annual salary to replace you
  • They can get rid of you when it suits them

Based on my experience, most people would actually be happier if they moved around a bit more.  They'd be better managers.  They'd be better employees and better consumers of companies' largess.

I suspect that's not a popular view either.

However...

Don't mistake this for a view that the Fifa head's comments are correct, or that Ronaldo should move.  Leave that view to politicians and back-seat football pundits.

/df


AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Published 10 July 2008 11:41 by David Ferrabee

Comment Notification

If you would like to receive an email when updates are made to this post, please register here

Subscribe to this post's comments using RSS

Comments

  • Indy said:

    It's worth noting that footballers really are in a somewhat different situation to most of us.

    If your significant other got a job in Madrid, you might decide to follow her and get a job in that city too. You are under contract to H&K, but whilst there are notice periods and non-compete clauses, any decent solicitor can get you off and working for a company in Madrid in six months at the most.

    The technical situation for Ronaldo is quite different, Man Utd hold his registration for the duration of his contract. Thus, for as long as they keep paying him he cannot ply his trade for any other FIFA registered football team. It's what the "transfer system" is built on. To that extent he is locked in more deeply than the average worker.

    [Of course, as far as we know, there's no reason to have sympathy, per se, with his desire to move, there are no personal circumstances, although it does rain a lot in Manchester.]

    If Ronaldo is really serious about moving to Madrid, then this latest round of PR will be a prelude to him challenging the validity of the "player registration scheme" in the European Court.

    July 10, 2008 16:58

Leave a Comment

(required) 
(optional)
(required) 
Submit