Welcome to Collective Conversation Sign in | Join | Help

The Asian Century - Glenn Schloss

 
Political, economic, business and social events and trends in the Asia Pacific which impact corporate reputations, brands and governments

This t shirt will get you arrested in Hong Kong – who says Asian marketing is not creative?

Attachment: GOD T-shirt.jpg (13465 bytes)

[Photo: Apple Daily] 

 The Chinese characters on this t shirt - seized with hundreds during a police raid on a trendy fashion outlet Thursday in Hong Kong - say "14K". That's the second biggest triad, or organised crime gang, in "Asia's world city". Who says Asian marketing and branding isn't innovative or creative enough?

Police swooped on the headquarters of G.O.D. (Goods of Desire), arresting 17 staff including sales people and designers for selling the t shirts. Triads have long been a menace in Hong Kong to the extent that the law prevents anybody from claiming to be a triad or possessing any insignia related to the gangs.  

The fashion for ironical statements on t shirts which has been sweeping the globe has clearly been gripping Hong Kong too, shirts bearing cannabis leaves and marijuana leaves are popular. Whether the 14K shirt episode is a step too far or the police have overreacted will be decided in the courts of law and public debate. Already media have suggested freedom of expression extends to the wearing of t shirts. Apple Daily, the local equivalent of a racy tabloid which also advocates democracy, shouted sarcastically about the raid on its front page: "14K t shirts confiscated - police put on big show"

G.O.D. is a great Hong Kong lifestyle, fashion and furniture brand oozing creative flair. It evokes an East-meets-West mood which captures the current zeitgeist. Its handbags are fashion items - featuring pictures of Chinese-language classified newspapers or red, white and blue clutches as a twist on the much larger, plastic bags used by domestic helpers or the elderly to lug goods around, known locally as "amah bags" or "Kowloon Samsonites".

Its "Delay No More" t shirts and fashion line sells incredibly well, given the pronunciation of the English phrase in Cantonese sounds similar to the local insult suggesting something offensive involving your mother.

It has won creative design prizes from local establishment bodies. Asia needs more brands and marketing like this which taps into local tastes while reinforcing high design standards.

However, unless you are an advocate of "any publicity is good PR" methods, G.O.D. could have followed some basic communications protocols in Asia:

  • Don't do anything illegal or (in this case) which is in the grey zone until ambiguity is clarified - triad symbols are extremely sensitive in Hong Kong and the law forbidding their use is well known
  • If in doubt about any commercial activity, seek legal advice or discuss informally with the authorities before setting off
  • If a law appears wrong or stifles a legitimate business activity, mount a carefully-planned public affairs or lobbying campaign - don't get caught selling a product (this had been on sale for a couple of months) unless the risks associated with high profile arrests, extensive media coverage (no matter how sympathetic) and an unhappy police force are those that you are willing to bear

Nevertheless, here's to the team at G.O.D. - in the pursuit of innovation and creativity, artists and designers sometimes cross the line. From a communications perspective, the most important thing is to demonstrate a commitment to operating within the law or having the law clarified. In the final analysis, G.O.D. is a business, not an artists' collective. 

www.goodsofdesire.com

HONG KONG, November 2 2007


AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Published 02 November 2007 19:56 by Glenn Schloss
Attachment(s): GOD T-shirt.jpg

Comments

  • Mike said:

    Cool story:) Is it 14K or 41K - it says 14K in the beginning, then 41K:)?

    November 4, 2007 09:08
  • Glenn Schloss said:

    Mike, Glad you enjoyed it. Thanks for pointing out the typo (fixed now!).

    Here's a quick update from after I filed this piece. G.O.D. issued an apology (good PR move to express concern), explaining the design was inspired by an old film poster or CD cover and that it resembled a gold plate Chinese brides wore on their necks in days gone by but the firm was unaware of the triad connotations (possible credibility issues there). It will also seek legal advice over sensitive designs in future (smart move). Reassuringly, co-founder Douglas Young, said G.O.D. would remain committed to its "playful and vivid style".

    November 5, 2007 02:04
  • Michael Netzley said:

    I will be interested to see how this plays out for G.O.D.  Knowing that we tend to desire things we cannot have, I have to wonder if the police raid might actually increase the desirability of G.O.D. products?  I will keep an eye on this.

    November 6, 2007 14:15
  • Glenn Schloss said:

    Yep good point Michael, these t shirts are likely to become collectors items. Apparently they hadn't been selling like hot cakes before the raid and now have been pulled from the shelves (for the time being).

    G.O.D. co-founder Douglas Young has said they now have received many e-mails from customers wanting to get their hands on one.

    November 7, 2007 03:59
New Comments to this post are disabled

About Glenn Schloss

Glenn is H&K's regional director for corporate communications, Asia Pacific. Based in Hong Kong, he is also head of public affairs there. Before embarking on a consulting career, Glenn was a journalist for 15 years including eight years at South China Morning Post where he was an investigative reporter and also covered Asian politics, economics, business, diplomacy and security. As a journalist in Australia, Glenn reported on Federal politics from the Parliamentary press gallery in Canberra for News Corporation's capital city newspapers across the nation. Born in Brisbane, he has lived in Hong Kong for 12 years having been drawn to the region by a lifelong passion for Asian politics, history and culture.